September 5, 2023

Tax Tips from Social Media: Beware of What Sounds Too Good to Be True

While social media, including TikTok, has made tax advice more accessible than ever, it’s crucial to approach such tips with skepticism. Just because a tax tip goes viral does not inherently make it valuable or correct. A case in point is the recent buzz around the so-called “Augusta Rule” on a platform previously known as Twitter.

Understanding the Augusta Rule

Named after the famed Augusta National Golf Course which hosts the Masters annually, the Augusta Rule or section 280A of the tax code permits homeowners to rent their personal residence for less than 15 days a year without reporting the rental income or deducting any expenses. Introduced in 1976, the rule was crafted in response to the evident income potential for local homeowners around such events. The idea was to prevent short-term rentals, which aren’t intended as business operations, from being taxed.

However, things took a twist when a TikTok reel, later shared on Twitter, touted a business strategy: businesses would rent a space in the owner’s house for monthly meetings, pay the owner, claim a deduction, and the owner would earn tax-free due to the Augusta Rule. Sounds flawless, right?

The Sinopoli Case: An Eye-Opener

The recent Tax Court case, Gary J. Sinopoli, Jr. and Melissa M. Sinopoli vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, offers a deep dive into this strategy’s practical implications. The case revolved around a group of medical professionals who formed an S corporation, Planet LA, LLC. Their strategy was to host meetings in their homes and pay rent from the business, excluding this income using the Augusta Rule.

Upon audit, inconsistencies arose. The company had deducted a total of $290,900 for these alleged payments to the taxpayers over almost three years. The Tax Court found the deductions to be inflated and permitted only a fraction of the claimed amounts. This supposed tax-saving strategy, in reality, only saved the taxpayers roughly $2,000 per year, excluding potential penalties, interest, or fees from the audit.

Further, in a separate scheme, the IRS disallowed nearly $1 million in expenses for the three years, reasoning that these expenses weren’t actual marketing expenses. It paints a clear picture: while tax strategies might look promising on the surface, diving into the details is paramount.

The Takeaway

It’s important to remember that the tax code is intricate, filled with subtle nuances and interdependencies. While tax-saving opportunities are definitely out there, and it’s worthwhile to explore them, relying solely on social media for advice can be risky.

Should you come across a seemingly groundbreaking tax tip, take a moment to consult with a tax professional. Their expertise will help you discern between what’s legitimate and what’s a stretch. As the adage goes, “Pigs get fat, hogs get slaughtered.” Aim for smart, sustainable tax strategies rather than fleeting loopholes.

If you have questions or concerns regarding any tax advice you see on TikTok or any other social media, please feel free to contact us.

You can follow Rebekah Roy’s TikTok here: